Broadcasting Spam into Space 218
A reader writes "Apparently frustrated by the crackdown on SPAMers by ISPs around the world, a group of Davis, California innovators made headlines this week in the Sacramento Bee by unveiling their "intergalactic communication system (U.S. Patent Pending)" which will beam unsolicited email into outer space. According to one of the founders, "this is the ultimate expression of free speech", but it will cost the general public $10.95 to have a 1000 word message launched. "
a solution at last? (Score:1)
That's what I want to see...
Anyone enter the contest? (Score:1)
Dear Inteligent Non-Earth based life,
Please allow me to apologize in the upmost for any further unsolicited spam that you may receive from our planet.
Any such messages should not be taken as a representation of inteligence on our planet.
If you find the said messages annoying, feel free to stop by and prosecute the people who sent the message, most of the planet would be quite happy to help.
Please dont decide to stop the spam by destroying our planet (Althought vapourizing those who sent the message might win you world wide gratatude).
Yours Truely.
Nocturnal.
(A concerned resident of Earth)
Re:My favorite part (Score:1)
Damnit, are they saying that when aliens recieve offensive email and blast us outta the sky, we can't sue Bentspace.com?
SirSlud
Re:My favorite part (Score:1)
Eight Steps to Futility (Score:2)
Secondly, the signal will be intermittent, so won't show up any more than the WOW! signal did on Earth, even if it -did- reach someone.
Thirdly, noise will garble any message beyond the point of being interpretable.
Fourthly, there is no way an alien race is going to be able to interpret ASCII text in any useful way, even if they did receive the message intact.
Fifthly, even if the aliens broke the ASCII code, they are hardly likely to know English, or any other Terran language.
Sixthly, even if the message was recieved and understood, given the timescales involved, it might be several hundred years before any reply would ever reach Earth, by which time the computer the message was to be delivered to would no longer exist, causing the reply to bounce.
Seventhly, even if the Internet still existed, and a computer with the correct name was present, with a mail server that still recognised that format of message, nobody on the receiving end who knew what the message was a reply to would still be alive.
Eighthly, even if someone DID know what the reply was for, and received it, and could interpret it (given natural language shifts), they would have no means of guaging it's authenticity or source, so rendering it useless.
Call an exorcist (Score:1)
The internet is possessed by the ghost of P.T Barnham !!!
Re:Does it seem like the Slashdot main page is fro (Score:1)
-blue
Re:Half-watt, let's do numbers (Score:1)
Here's another problem: These clowns aren't even going to direct the signal to a particular star. They are just letting their transmitter sweep across the sky as the Earth rotates. I guess they hope those ET's are listening at just the right moment to hear the signal.
Well anyway, I'm just wasting my time here, because it is just a huge scam in the end. i hope nobody has sent in they $10.
No, they're gonna use the grey dress code... (Score:1)
The only problem is any aliens who would respond are too dumb to have the technology to respond. There goes the $60,000 investment. DOH!!!!!!
I suppose if it doesn't work out the spammers can go back to cutting crop circles.
Re:msgto.com (Score:1)
I really wish CmdrTaco, Hemos, Roblimo, CowboyNeal, JonKatz, or someone else would pay more attention to this service. It really looks like a complete solution to spam. If it's as good as it seems, it would be worth someone's time to create a simplified daemon that would act only as a mail filter. But since this article is a day old, I can expect at most 2 people to read this!
i can see it now (Score:1)
Re:Half witt? Not enough to remember very good (Score:2)
The post above was right, for reflections the returned power is 1/^4 of the distance to the target.
Power from Tx to Rx falls off at 1/^2 * distance.
the Anonymous Cypher
Silence (Score:1)
There is absolutely no practical application to this, and the chances that someone will actually get the signal are virtually nonexistant. I guess it's pretty cool to let people pretend that they're talking to aliens. Essentially, this is what is happening here. But you won't see me spending 11 bucks on this.
---
Re:Silence (Score:1)
---
Another funny qoute... (Score:1)
Indeed! That includes accidentally making your e-mail address (since they include the message headers) availiable to whatever galactic spammers exist... "That's no moon - it's a mobile spammer-friendly ISP!".
If you want to see the powerful server that will be packaging your messages for its lengthy half-watt journey through the cosmos, have a look at this webcam [bentspace.com].
What a bunch of crap (Score:1)
And what makes people think non-earthlings know English (or French, or Sanskrit, or whatever) anyway? Unless the signal is very powerful and being recieved frequently, they'll probably just treat it like just another freak signal from the cosmos (which wouldn't be too far from the truth, really).
I think you can figure out how to email me
Hmph. So what? (Score:1)
Spam, like it or not, is an economic and technical problem. Treating it as if it were a political problem not only won't be a solution, it will threaten freedom of expression on the 'net.
JMR
hmmm.. i think i'll post (Score:1)
Spam into outer space? What shit. (Score:1)
ultimate in senselessness and idiocy. You never
cease to find dumber and dumber morons on this
planet.
Re:Yikes (Score:2)
This should read "but until _NOW_"
Sorry.
Yes, I am an idiot.
--Shoeboy
Just what we need. (Score:1)
Patent Pending? (Score:1)
First of, let me just say that this is the stupidest thing that I've ever heard of. But that's not what worries me...
The post on Slashdot mentions that there is a patent pending for this (although I didn't see it in the article). I think this is a bit silly now, but could in theory give them a monopoly on all e-mail sent between planets. Just think about what would happen if we made a base on the moon: you wouldn't be able to send e-mail because they would have the patent. Depending on the wording (and lawyers), it could even cover all e-mail send via radio waves.
Scary...
-ElJefe
ET (Score:1)
That's assuming that the ET communicated in any of the forms of "language" known to man...
Re:My favorite part (Score:1)
Oh great... (Score:1)
Sounds like a new market... (Score:1)
Get that Spammer with SpamCop! [spamcop.net]
Re:Half-watt transmitter? (Score:1)
I was curious about what Eric Overfield an undergraduate computer science major said - that the messages will include coding that an ET theoretically could decipher to send a reply. I wonder if that means they're sending an RFC first.
I guess they're not using AOL's Instant Message format. Hooray for standards!
wtf? (Score:1)
PIIIIIIGS IIIIIIIN SPAAAAAAAAACE!!!! (Score:1)
(Hormel SPAM = Shoulder of Pork and hAM)
P.S. speaking of, anybody seen the new Muppet movie? Any reviews? I always knew Gonzo had to be an alien....
#include "disclaim.h"
"All the best people in life seem to like LINUX." - Steve Wozniak
so much for seti@home... (Score:1)
Justin
Re:oops (Score:1)
A/S/L?
Half-watt transmitter? (Score:1)
Great...Now those aliens will never talk to us (Score:1)
Re:Half-watt, let's do numbers (Score:1)
woof woof (Score:2)
We have free sex pics of young women sex that work at home sex to raise money sex to help their legal and sex financial problems/opportunities sex all at no sex risk to you!
Unfortunately, the little green men read this as:
blah blah sex blah blah blah sex blah blah blah sex blah blah sex blah blah blah sex blah blah sex blah blah sex blah blah.
(with apologies to Larson and Ginger).
My favorite part (Score:4)
Oh good, I'm glad they've made provisions.
--
Oh, great. Now we're screwed. (Score:1)
At any rate, only an idiot would shell out the $$ for this. "'Admittedly, it is a weak signal, but it does go on forever,' Snow said." The same could be said about any electromagnetic signal. You could say the same about a toy walkie-talkie. Only idiots will pay for this service...and I don't want to know the things they would say. I hope that those messages really aren't heard by any alien civilzations, for humanity's sake.
Some people... (Score:1)
Did anyone think that the SETI program is just a human attempt to understand the spam aliens have been sending us?
Some people have too much money on their hands and an overdeveloped love of technology with no apparent usefulness. How sad that they think American children can create meaningful commentary in less than 1,000 words.
J.
I'm doing this right now.. (Score:1)
For a limited time the first 1000 people can have their pictures sent as an attachment. Aliens can speak MIME!
small print : Some conditions may apply messages not actually sent to space. Money will be laundered. Messages will be laughed at.
Wow thats just great (Score:1)
I'm doing this right now.. (Score:1)
For a limited time the first 1000 people can have their pictures sent as an attachment. Aliens can speak MIME!
small print : Some conditions may apply messages not actually sent to space. Money will be laundered. Messages will be laughed at.
My favorite part (Score:1)
Oh good, I'm glad they've made provisions.
--
Re:Half-watt, let's do numbers (Score:1)
What an ignorant idea. (Score:1)
Re:My favorite part (Score:1)
Content Type: text/x-interstellar transmission (Score:2)
Yes, you are an alien. (Score:1)
-Adam
Re:Patent Pending? (Score:1)
When's the IPO?? (Score:1)
Re:California (Score:1)
Scary scenario... (Score:1)
If they beam spam into outer space and it reflects off astronomical debris and bounces back after a century
ALIENS' MESSAGE TO EARTH: "MAKE MONEY FAST!"
or
ALIEN CIVILIZATION OFFERS 100 FREE HOURS OF AOL!
or worst of all
HISTORIC FIRST CONTACT: ALIENS PROMISE FREE DAILY PORN IN YOUR EMAIL!
L.
Re:The Universe is a closed hypersphere, right? (Score:1)
...
Re:Scary scenario... (Score:1)
So.. (Score:1)
I loved that segment on the Muppet Show..
Ahhh, dammit all to hell... (Score:1)
Seriously, this strikes me as being a contender for the stupidest thing yet. But it makes money, so they'll be able to go public and make a ton of coin on other people's stupidity.
Meanwhile, once the reruns of Gilligan's Island stop, ET will then get spammed.
Dangerous! (Score:1)
I would...
Dangers of Interstellar Spam (Score:2)
From: zork@gmaps.beta.lyrae.net
Subject: GRBH advisory
Dear Earthlings:
We have received numerous reports that your planet has been broadcasting unsolicited commercial email (commonly referred to as "spam"). Please be advised that your planet is now a candidate for Galactic Real-time Black Hole (GRBH) listing.
We understand that, as a young and technologically backward species, you may not be familiar with the rules of Galactic Etiquette. However, ignorance is no excuse for your present behavior. We have also heard that your planetary network maintains a so-called "black-hole list." Please note that your penchant for colorful metaphors is unique among sentient species; we of the galactic community are rather more literal-minded.
We personally doubt that you wish to see your planet torn apart by a gravitational vortex, so we urge you to cease transmitting spam immediately. Please inform us by interocitor of your intent to comply within the next 100 centons.
RBL (Score:1)
Jamie McCarthy
Bah! (Score:1)
I'm just waiting for the day when the IGPD (Intergalatic Police Dep't) sends us a $20,000,000,000,000,000,000 fine for noise pollution.
And the Martian's answer back,. (Score:1)
Not bad for our first interplanetary communication.
Re:Half-witt transmitter? (Score:1)
Sure, but there's also the inverse square law to worry about. I really doubt that current human technology is capable of recieving such a signal much farther out than our solar system. Infact, radio and TV broadcast signals that have passed out through the atmosphere into space are probably what aliens would run across first, considering that such signals start out at many thousands of watts, at the transmitter.
Re:ET (Score:2)
"R U M/F?"
LART? (Score:1)
-:)
Re:End of the world?? (Score:1)
Re:LART? (Score:1)
Boneheaded Idea of the Year Award (Score:1)
[1] - It's amazing what passes for innovation nowadays.
[2] - I'm not sure what more amazing: a) that they thought this was an idea worth patenting or b.) that the U.S. Patent Office will probably award the patent!
[3] - How many bozos at this price will it take for this group of innovators to become millionaires? Sadly, it'll this'll probably happen too.
Seeing as how the Andromeda galaxy (our closest neighboring galaxy if you don't count the Magellanic Clouds) is 2e+06 lights away, I wouln't ask for a return receipt for that e-mail if I were you.
As an aside, when I used Alta Vista to find info on Andromeda galaxy, the page contained a link labeled "The RealNames link takes you directly to Andromeda Galaxy.". Now those guys at RealNames are doing some real innovation!
More humor: Make Hydrogen Fast! (Score:3)
This really works!
Just send 5*10^50 atoms of hydrogen to each of the five star systems listed below. Then, add your own system to the top of the list, delete the system at the bottom, and send out copies of this message to 100 other solar systems.
If you follow these instructions, within 0.25 galactic rotations you are guaranteed to receive enough hydrogen in return to power your civilization until the heat death of the universe!
Ripe for a Practical Joke (Score:1)
Problems:
properly targeting the Bent Space dish
positioning the balloon directly over the dish
justifying the waste of all that money for a stupid stunt like this
Of course, the last could be said of the Bent Space "service" as well.
______________________________
I can just see it now . . . . (Score:1)
.
.
.
3 galactic years later: Zig why do I keep getting this message offering a chance to make 50,000 a year. . .
ZAP!!!!!!!! By by earth
New idea? (Score:1)
Awful (Score:1)
--------
"I already have all the latest software."
Not a bad price... (Score:1)
how much do corporate subscriptions cost? (Score:1)
Wasn't this supposed to be on Segfault? (Score:1)
/El Niño
Re:Oh, great. Now we're screwed. (Score:1)
Anyway, never forget that there is a chance to find just a bunch of complete "Me Tarzan, you Jane" idiots out there. Gee, that would be something 8))
Alternative version of "Urusei Yatsura" beginning -- Ataru sent email (in his usual style) into space, Oni-aliens liked it and decided that the Earth is a nice place to conquer?
Nah, makes too much sense.
spam wonderful spam (Score:1)
Re:Half watt? Not enough to go very far (Score:1)
I can just see it now . . . . (Score:1)
.
.
.
3 galactic years later: Zig why do I keep getting this message offering a chance to make 50,000 a year. . .
ZAP!!!!!!!! By by earth
Re: My email goes to space all the time (Score:1)
I'm going to use a plastic snow dish, a turkey baster and a modem coupler to make a signal dish and claim I spent $60k on it too!
msgto.com (Score:1)
(BTW I tried to get this posted as a main
How does the conversion work? (Score:1)
OK, I'm going to need some clarification on this statement. Are they saying that the messages are sent with a key? If so, how does the key work and what does that key decipher the messages to, Phoenician letters that form English words? If so, what the hell are aliens going to do with that? Imagine how anticlimactic it would have been in the move Contact if once they had finally decoded the complex radio signals they turned out to be a couple pages of alien letters that formed alien words from a complex language that highly intelligent aliens from the same planet have a hard time learning. Unless this system turns all of the e-mails into pictograms or basic mathematical equations this whole thing is a total waste of time.
I guess one other possibility is that the aliens have intercepted our TV and radio transmissions for years and have somehow managed to separate the various languages and learn English or what ever language some sap plans to send into outer space (by the way, unless they get a lot of Sesame Street they still wouldn't recognize letters). This of course would mean that they already: A. Know we are here, and B. Have chosen not to contact us (at least not directly). So do you think that sending some week signal into space that represents text that is encoded using some non-standard method is gonna make a difference?
You would have a better chance of contacting intelligent life if you went out side every night and flashed prime number patterns with a flashlight into the night sky.
Didn't these fools see "Independence Day"? (Score:1)
Well... (Score:1)
"FIFTEEN-ARMED SEX MOMMA WANTS YOUR E-MAIL"
"COME TO EARTH--FREE BEER, BLOWJOBS, AND MEAT!"
So what happens if the other planets decide to start spamming
Re:Half-watt, let's do numbers (Score:2)
.5/(4*pi*[4*300,000,000*60*60*24*365.24]^2)
1.6*10^-32 watts/meter^2
or if you have a really big radio telescope:
1.6*10^-26 watts/kilometer^2
or if the entire surface of your planet is a radio telescope:
4.1*10^-18 watts/half of a earth sized planet.
No one is gonna be picking this up, i don't care how clever they are, the signal is simply to weak.
Any background radiation at all will completely swamp it.
Re:Half-witt transmitter? (Score:2)
(A beam will still fall off with distance, as it will diffuse, some.)
However, radio noise from natural sources (such as the sun, the planets, toasters, etc.) will probably drown out anything transmitted, at any real distance, given the equiptment used.
well then (Score:2)
Ohhh their "powerful computers" will do some magic and let you know when your email has been sent. And I'll send you an email right after I tap out your message.
I gotta find the twinks who actually try to do this. I'm sure they'll buy my new death ray too.
Silly question is Dogbert running BentSpace?
-cpd
I've got a better idea... (Score:2)
- Dave
"Take what thou hast and give it to the poor."
Re:Patent Pending? (Score:2)
Re:My favorite part (Score:2)
Exchange Rates (Score:2)
If ET *does* buy into my patented multi-level marketing plan, which has worked for thousands of Earthlings, and absolutely legal and guaranteed to earn you $5000/week while you loose 50 lbs/month, I'm going to need to know how much of his money it takes to make just $9.99 US.
I can just see it now... (Score:2)
Meezledorp! look what i got in my inbox! Free Sex for 5 days! Earth girls *are* easy!
Gwazzlenap, we must find this Pamala Anderson now! Set course for Earth at maximum fizzlegargs!
The Universe is a closed hypersphere, right? (Score:3)
I reckon they can be sued for that, polluting Australian airwaves and all.
Half watt? Not enough to go very far (Score:3)
In reality, there is a limit where a signal can no longer be detected. Because of the background radiation of 3 degrees kelvin, and a host of other factors, eventually even a
Their site is pretty funny, they aren't taking themselves too seriously. But there isn't anywhere they tell about what frequency or coding scheme they are using. I'd love to know. I've just posted a message to their board (number 3, they don't have a slashdot base of users, yet)
the AC
Re:Half-witt transmitter? (Score:2)
And the farther spam travels from earth, the better
Re:Andromeda? (Score:2)
Re:msgto.com (Score:2)
Re:Spam ? (Score:2)
Intelligent_Alien@Home.MilkyWay.Galaxy.Universe (Score:2)
[include quotes of MoneyScam rich customers here...]
If you wish to be removed from our list and not receive our mailings in the future, send 10,000,000 monetary units!
Yours in InstaWealth,
A. Bilfred Spammer,
President, MoneyScam Industries
(Null3928@bigfoot.com)
Oh great... (Score:3)
:P
PS: Can I change my ISP to another planet? This one has bad service and is *way* too busy even though the phone-to-customer ratio is something like 2:1!
New buisness venture to seek out subterranean life (Score:3)
SEATTLE Shoeboy Industries, a local high tech firm known for their extensive bong testing labs has developed a new technique to allow individuals to send money towards the center of the Earth.
"Scientists have long speculated that there might be vast populations of intelligent beings living in a vast hollow cave within the earth's core." observered Shoeboy, founder and CEO of Shoeboy Industries, "Our process allows you to send money to these tunneling superbeings. We take your money and deposit it in my bank account. I then write a check to the underground men and deposit it as close to the earth's core as is possible with current technology."
Little is known about the exact method Shoeboy uses to send these checks, but many industry insiders have speculated that it involves a highly specialized tool known as a 'shovel.' Such a tool could be purchased at the 'Tweedy and Pop' hardware store down the street from Shoeboy's apartment, but until know, industry analysts have considered the $14.95 price tag too high for a small firm like Shoeboy Industries.
When questioned, Shoeboy revealed that his firm had recieved extensive backing from a prominent venture capital firm. "We used the words 'Internet' and 'e-commerce' in the same sentence and these dudes dropped 20 million on the table." reported Shoeboy. "We were all like, whoa dude think of all the twinkies we could buy."
When asked if he thought that people would pay money to send a message to recipients whose very existence is a remote theoretical possibility Shoeboy replied "well, there's a whole mess of gullible idiots out there on the web."
--Shoeboy