Hospital Network Admin Used Fake Identity For 35 Years (thegazette.com) 88
An anonymous reader writes: Could you imagine discovering that your identity had been used to take out fraudulent loans and when you tried to resolve the issue by providing your state ID and Social Security card you were instead arrested, charged with multiple felonies, jailed for over a year, incarcerated in a mental hospital and given psychotropic drugs, eventually to be released with a criminal record and a judge's order that you could no longer use your real name? As dystopian as this might sound, it actually happened. And it was only after the victim learned his oppressor worked for The University of Iowa Hospital and contacted their security department was the investigation taken seriously leading to the perpetrator's arrest. The Gazette reports: Matthew David Keirans, 58, was convicted of one count of false statement to a National Credit Union Administration insured institution -- punishable by up to 30 years in federal prison -- and one count of aggravated identity theft -- punishable by up to two years in federal prison. Keirans worked as a systems architect in the hospital's IT department from June 28, 2013 to July 20, 2023, when he was terminated for misconduct related to the identity theft investigation. Keirans worked at the hospital under the name William Donald Woods, an alias he had been using since about 1988, when he worked with the real William Woods at a hot dog cart in Albuquerque, N.M. [...] By 2013, Keirans had moved to eastern Wisconsin. He started his IT job with UI Hospitals and worked remotely. He earned more than $700,000 in his 10 years working for the hospital. In 2023, his salary was $140,501, according to the hospital.
In 2019, the real William Woods was homeless, living in Los Angeles. He went to a branch of the national bank and explained that he recently discovered someone was using his credit and had accumulated a lot of debt. Woods didn't want to pay the debt and asked to know the account numbers for any accounts he had open at the bank so he could close them. Woods gave the bank employee his real Social Security card and an authentic California Identification card, which matched the information the bank had on file. Because there was a large amount of money in the accounts, the bank employee asked Woods a series of security questions that he was unable to answer. The bank employee called Keirans, whose the phone number was connected to the accounts. He answered the security questions correctly and said no one in California should have access to the accounts. The employee called the Los Angeles Police Department, and officers spoke with Woods and Keirans. Keirans faxed the Los Angeles officers a copy of Woods' Social Security card and birth certificate, as well as a Wisconsin driver's license Keirans had acquired under Woods' name. The driver's license had the name William David Woods -- David is Keirans' real middle name -- rather than William Donald Woods. When questioned, Keiran told an LAPD officer he sometimes used David as a middle name, but his real name was William Donald Woods. The real Woods was arrested and charged with identity theft and false impersonation, under a misspelling of Keirans' name: Matthew Kierans.
Because Woods continued to insist, throughout the judicial process, that he was William Woods and not Matthew Kierans, a judge ruled in February 2020 that he was not mentally competent to stand trial and he was sent to a mental hospital in California, where he received psychotropic medication and other mental health treatment. In March 2021, Woods pleaded no contest to the identity theft charges -- meaning he accepted the conviction but did not admit guilt. He was sentenced to two years imprisonment with credit for the two years he already served in the county jail and the hospital and was released. He was also ordered to pay $400 in fines and to stop using the name William Woods. He did not stop. Woods continued to attempt to regain his identity by filing customer disputes with financial organizations in an attempt to clear his credit report. He also reached out to multiple law enforcement agencies, including the Hartland Police Department in Wisconsin, where Keirans lived. Woods eventually discovered where Keirans was working, and in January 2023 he reached out to the University of Iowa Hospitals' security department, who referred his complaint to the University of Iowa Police Department.
University of Iowa Police Detective Ian Mallory opened an investigation into the case. Mallory found the biological father listed on Woods' birth certificate -- which both Woods and Keirans had sent him an official copy of -- and tested the father's DNA against Woods' DNA. The test proved Woods was the man's son. On July 17, 2023, Mallory interviewed Keirans. He asked Keirans what his father's name was, and Keirans accidentally gave the name of his own adoptive father. Mallory then confronted Keirans with the DNA evidence, and Keirans responded by saying, "my life is over" and "everything is gone." He then confessed to the prolonged identity theft, according to court documents. The full story can be ready via The Gazette.
In 2019, the real William Woods was homeless, living in Los Angeles. He went to a branch of the national bank and explained that he recently discovered someone was using his credit and had accumulated a lot of debt. Woods didn't want to pay the debt and asked to know the account numbers for any accounts he had open at the bank so he could close them. Woods gave the bank employee his real Social Security card and an authentic California Identification card, which matched the information the bank had on file. Because there was a large amount of money in the accounts, the bank employee asked Woods a series of security questions that he was unable to answer. The bank employee called Keirans, whose the phone number was connected to the accounts. He answered the security questions correctly and said no one in California should have access to the accounts. The employee called the Los Angeles Police Department, and officers spoke with Woods and Keirans. Keirans faxed the Los Angeles officers a copy of Woods' Social Security card and birth certificate, as well as a Wisconsin driver's license Keirans had acquired under Woods' name. The driver's license had the name William David Woods -- David is Keirans' real middle name -- rather than William Donald Woods. When questioned, Keiran told an LAPD officer he sometimes used David as a middle name, but his real name was William Donald Woods. The real Woods was arrested and charged with identity theft and false impersonation, under a misspelling of Keirans' name: Matthew Kierans.
Because Woods continued to insist, throughout the judicial process, that he was William Woods and not Matthew Kierans, a judge ruled in February 2020 that he was not mentally competent to stand trial and he was sent to a mental hospital in California, where he received psychotropic medication and other mental health treatment. In March 2021, Woods pleaded no contest to the identity theft charges -- meaning he accepted the conviction but did not admit guilt. He was sentenced to two years imprisonment with credit for the two years he already served in the county jail and the hospital and was released. He was also ordered to pay $400 in fines and to stop using the name William Woods. He did not stop. Woods continued to attempt to regain his identity by filing customer disputes with financial organizations in an attempt to clear his credit report. He also reached out to multiple law enforcement agencies, including the Hartland Police Department in Wisconsin, where Keirans lived. Woods eventually discovered where Keirans was working, and in January 2023 he reached out to the University of Iowa Hospitals' security department, who referred his complaint to the University of Iowa Police Department.
University of Iowa Police Detective Ian Mallory opened an investigation into the case. Mallory found the biological father listed on Woods' birth certificate -- which both Woods and Keirans had sent him an official copy of -- and tested the father's DNA against Woods' DNA. The test proved Woods was the man's son. On July 17, 2023, Mallory interviewed Keirans. He asked Keirans what his father's name was, and Keirans accidentally gave the name of his own adoptive father. Mallory then confronted Keirans with the DNA evidence, and Keirans responded by saying, "my life is over" and "everything is gone." He then confessed to the prolonged identity theft, according to court documents. The full story can be ready via The Gazette.
Death Penalty (Score:5, Insightful)
Good for the Iowa detective for having a clue and a brain.
The rest of them would be happy to convict on a Capital Offense on their flimsy evidence.
Re: (Score:2)
Good for the Iowa detective for having a clue and a brain.
I call shenanigans. I have it on good authority that the police are completely stymied unless they have full access to everyone's encrypted smart devices!
They used to, now they have magic AI powered case solving boxes.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Bizarre (Score:4, Funny)
The only way this could've been weirder is if the homeless guy's last name was Braxton and he claimed to be a Starfleet officer trying to protect the 29th century.
Re: (Score:2)
And Wesley and the Traveller showed up to save the day. :D
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
I tried but I couldn't get an SSN or DL with a name of '93 Escort Wagon'.
Re: Bizarre (Score:2)
Try "Ford Perfect" instead.
Re: (Score:2)
I tried but I couldn't get an SSN or DL with a name of '93 Escort Wagon'.
The world really isn't ready for two of me anyway...
Re: (Score:2)
"I just came back to see my great, great, great...grandma Toni."
Law and Order (Score:1)
Re: Law and Order (Score:4, Interesting)
Seriously though, judges have way too much power and way too little accountability. Many lives are ruined by lazy and biased judges.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: Law and Order (Score:4, Informative)
I agree. I don't trust Judges. Thank god for DNA.
Sure, but none of this would have happened without a competent detective doing enough good police work to trigger the DNA test. In the end, like any justice system, the US one is dependent from the patrol officer all the way up to SCOTUS on begin staffed with good competent people. However, in this day and age where the priority is stuffing the court system full of political appointees whose primary purpose is push an ideological agenda and competence is an optional extra, such partisan dumf**kery is slowly destroying Americans' access to competently administered justice.
Re: (Score:1)
The Iowa investigator noticed this and when the grifter gave the wrong name for his father they decided to verify things with DNA.
Re: (Score:2)
i find it hard to agree with someone who chose the username "ihavesexwithcollies"
Re: Law and Order (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
sure, let me just search goatse and tubgirl first though
Honey, I'm Home! (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Honey, I'm Home! (Score:4, Funny)
Re: (Score:1)
Why would someone mod this down? Sympathy for the imposter?
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Why would someone mod this down? Sympathy for the imposter?
Composter Syndrome.
Re: (Score:2, Informative)
Why would someone mod this down? Sympathy for the imposter?
Moderation abuse is rampant on Slashdot and there's no way to report it. In the past, there were enough mod points passed around that it wasn't much of an issue. Have you meta-moderated today? https://slashdot.org/metamod.p... [slashdot.org]
Re: (Score:2)
Sympathy for the imposter?
Please, allow me to introduce myself...
Re: (Score:2)
And then gets immedeatelly divorced and end up in jail for failing to pay for child support. Yep, I can believe that.
Alimony, you forgot the alimony payments, based on his alter egos' far higher income.
Re: (Score:2)
> I'm wondering if the real William Woods is now considered owner of the home purchased by the impostor and legally married to the wife
Yes. He confronted the wife, who agreed this is the only logical course of action and they are having sex right now.
Re: Honey, I'm Home! (Score:2)
"...and they are having sex right now."
Prima Facie evidence that the couple are neither married, nor readers of /.
Re: (Score:2)
who agreed this is the only logical course of action
The Star Trek references are for the other thread further back.
Re: (Score:2)
Was the home purchased with cash or a mortgage? If the latter, there is probably some clause about the mortgage being invalid and ownership reverting to the bank if the application contained lies. His (presumably ex-) wife would likely make some claim over the value of it, given she was a victim as well.
As for being legally married, it depends what you mean. She married a different person, but various records will show she married Woods. Ideally she could obtain a divorce in the name of William Woods, to ma
Re: (Score:2)
If the latter, there is probably some clause about the mortgage being invalid and ownership reverting to the bank if the application contained lies.
Did you mean "the outstanding balance is due and payable immediately, and the bank will foreclose on the property if no payment is forthcoming?" Because "the bank gets the asset outright" isn't a thing.
Why? (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Implication he had a criminal record and the other dude didn't.
Re: (Score:2)
Why did this guy do it in the first place? And then why continue to double down on such a flimsy base?
I agree that the details are lacking but the article did mention some legal trouble for the accused when he was 16 years old, he was a runaway, car thief, and likely accused of other petty offenses. The charges were under his own name but with the charges being relatively minor they weren't going to put much effort into tracking him down. He shows up in a different state with an assumed ID, and with the real owner of that ID being largely off the grid from being homeless there wasn't much to raise any fla
How do you take back your life? (Score:3)
I'm wondering about that for the real Mr. Woods.
How does he get all that time he wasted trying to convince the authorities that he was, who he said he was.
He suffered in jail and a mental institution over it.
You can't give a person back that time lost, you can't.
Re: (Score:2)
There's apparently lots of money in those bank accounts, and they are in his name, so...
Re: (Score:2)
>"There's apparently lots of money in those bank accounts, and they are in his name, so..."
Yep, there should be two civil suits- one against the imposter, holding him financially responsible, and one against the government(s) that falsely convicted him.
You can't get your time back, but he should certainly be compensated.
Re: (Score:2)
You can't get your time back, but he should certainly be compensated.
His "no contest" plea is likely to make that very difficult to obtain.
Re: (Score:2)
>"His "no contest" plea is likely to make that very difficult to obtain."
Yeah, perhaps bad lawyering?
The burden of proof should have been on the government to prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that he was NOT who he claimed he was, not just throw him in a psyc ward (I think we might be missing some context and other info in the article/summary). That would have been a pretty high bar to pass, had he not plead guilty (no contest is essentially the same thing). Of course, he didn't make things easier by
Re: (Score:2)
Yeah, perhaps bad lawyering?
Yes, because we simply don't fund the public defenders sufficiently for them to put on a good case.
Tell me again effective identity doesn't matter? (Score:2)
Would the government please get off their collective butts, and create effective biometric based identification? And since we're decades into the 'internet revolution'... something that works remotely as well as in person, and is supported everywhere (forced if necessary).
No, the public sector cannot do your work for you anymore (online identity authorities vs. registering with the government), and never really did it anyway. Stop pretending it's not your job.
And stop this stupidity of barring the one gro
Re: (Score:2)
I guess a good way to hold onto another person's identity is to quickly open a bunch of accounts and move a bunch of times so the real person can no longer answer the identity questions.
And the defense against that is to buy your own information from the dark web because the credit agencies aren't going to give it to you without answering the questions correctly.
It's like the guy who squatted in his own home to make the squatters leave. [youtube.com]
Re: (Score:2)
It's like the guy who squatted in his own home to make the squatters leave. [youtube.com]
I hate the culture that causes people to point at a fifteen minute youtube video to explain something that takes 15 seconds to read [nypost.com].
Re: (Score:3)
>"Would the government please get off their collective butts, and create effective biometric based identification?"
You have to create one that cannot be ABUSED. That is the danger. Things like fingerprints and DNA are extremely dangerous. Retinal scan would be reasonable, but it is also difficult and expensive to use.
Ironically, the ancient practice of using a footprint from the baby at the birthing hospital is not horrible. People don't leave footprints everywhere they go, and you can't just collect
What of the juidge (Score:5, Interesting)
A judge ordered a man to be confined to a mental ward and drugged for 2 years rather than order a proper investigation of a completely sane claim that he was actually who he was.
So will the judge be stepping down? Be photographed begging forgiveness on his knees while wearing a dunce cap? Say he's sorry in private and vow to do better? Anything? Beuller?
Re: (Score:2)
Good luck with judicial immunity.
Re: (Score:2)
What proper investigation? A judge had enough incriminating material in front of him and rendered a judgement based on the evidence he had. It's fun to shit on the legal system, but you seem to underestimate just how in depth this identity theft actually was. This wasn't some random dude stealing a guy's name to do one dodgy thing, this was a very in depth theft of someone's complete life including the issuing of official documents.
I'd prefer the very rare wrong judgement than having to get a DNA test ever
Re: (Score:1)
Oh do fuck off. A cursory examination of the facts would have thrown this into question, and thus further investigation. If you have had kids in your car who have eaten cotton candy, you might wanna sell it in case cops pull you over for some reason and one of their drug testing kids falsely identifies the sweet as meth. As happened to this woman, who was considering pleading guilty to charges she was innocent of, just to get on with her life. Until the state lab did an actual analysis, and found out oh dar
Re: (Score:2)
It is not, and never has been, a judges responsibility to present evidence in court.
That is the job of the lawyers representing the defendant. It is also their job to request and show reason for further investigation.
And that's the precise reason why the legal system in Common Law countries is utterly fucked-up and it's impossible for the poor to get actual justice, except by chance. You only get the evidence and legal arguments you can pay for.
In Roman law systems, it is absolutely the responsibility of the judge to ensure that enough evidence is collected to properly assess the case and provide an accurate judicial truth.
Now don't get me wrong, the poor can also be screwed up in a Roman law system, in special in case
Re: (Score:3)
It absolutely *IS* the judges responsibility to make sure there is adequate evidence before anyone is found guilty.
A judge has the power to overturn a jury verdict of guilty if he or she believes the prosecution pulled a fast one. A judge has the power to rule that a person wasn't given an adequate defense if the public defender is so over-loaded with cases that he cannot actually do his job (an all too common situation).
There absolutely is plenty of blame to go around in this case, but the buck stops at th
Re: (Score:2)
The responsibility was with his public defender, who did not do his job, and therefore rendered "ineffective assistance of counsel", as a result of a not enough staffing.
Re: (Score:1)
Bullshit. Cops, prosecutor and judge are responsible first and should serve time for what they put this guy through and then disbarred from their professions.
Re: (Score:2)
His primary evidence was "this sounds cuckoo". and a general belief that homeless people are unreliable. No ACTUAL evidence of anything. So without benefit of a jury, a man was locked up and drugged out of his mind. Even the old Soviet Union only did that to dissidents.
That's all getting uncomfortably close to deciding you're crazy because you maintain that you're innocent, so you better just plead guilty.
As for proper investigation, a private investigator was able to track down the father listed on the bir
Re: (Score:2)
That is one argument the other argument is you have guy that is in possession of a what appears to be a legitimate SSA card (not the strongest security on those), a birth certificate, and a state issued id; and he insists they are his.
He appears to be the right age / sex for these items.
Don't you at least want to see some evidence one or more of those items are forgeries?
If they are in fact documents created by the legitimate issuer or can't be shown to be fake don't think you ask - well then how and where
Re: (Score:2)
It seems more like a systemic failure. The guy was poor and often homeless, so he didn't have much access to good legal representation, or the ability to gather evidence to prove the fraud. Had he been given a good lawyer with plenty of time to examine his case, he might have prevailed in court.
The judge was likely just evaluating the evidence he had in front of him, and the arguments put forward by each side's lawyers.
Re: (Score:1)
The judge is responsible for making sure the court renders no decisions without proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Even if the defendant offers no defense at all.
In this case, there was no jury, there was only circumstantial evidence, and actual evidence was easy enough to find that a private investigator managed to do it. It absolutely *WAS* the judge's responsibility to throw the whole thing out until real evidence was presented somewhere. Instead, he ordered the defendant confined to a mental ward where he
An effective employee is lost? (Score:1)
I assume most people will get out the pitchforks here, but what about the long time employee that sounded like they were doing their job just fine? Sure they owed a lot of money, but that's true of many people today.
Yes, terrible stuff happened to the other person, but isn't that the fault of the people doing the acts themselves? And of the government for not being able to match the right person to the identity sooner?
DNA tests should be cheap today. And if we started using them instantly when relationsh
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:1)
I assume most people will get out the pitchforks here, but what about the long time employee that sounded like they were doing their job just fine? Sure they owed a lot of money, but that's true of many people today.
Had this been limited to stealing a couple beater cars 20 or so years ago, and handling his finances a bit poorly, then maybe I could be convinced to agree with you. He's been accused of many many counts of identity fraud (each loan, license, etc. would be a separate count even if he used the same ID each time) and is working as an IT professional in a hospital (which puts him in a position to commit ID fraud on others that were hospitalized and living "off the grid" like Woods was) which makes this a case
How the heck? (Score:4, Interesting)
Can't they interview family etc.? This is some truly dystopian shit. Put everyone who fucked this off in jail: Judge. prosecutor, and investigators.
Re: (Score:2)
Who is guilty in this case, and who is too quick to judge? In the matter of guilt, is it the public officials who have a sharply constrained budget to perform investigations, or the taxpayers who constrain the budgets of government agencies so they lack, in many cases, the resources to perform investigations that prevent miscarriages of justice? From an engineering mindset, I think it's clear that there is a tradeoff between resources allocated to services and the quality of the services that can be rendere
The full story can be ready via The Gazette..... (Score:3)
commentsubject (Score:1)
did wood's highschool not have yearbook photos in ~1980? any team/club photos that depict a "William Woods, second from right" who he should resemble more than keirans? especially if he has other past photos?
i get that he was poor and the justice system gave him all the justice poors get, but i'm surprised there was absolutely zero record of the man's history, a big blank space all the way up to DNA testing
Full name and birthdate can coincide (Score:5, Interesting)
Re: (Score:2)
How about For 18 years, I thought she was stealing my identity. Until I found her [theguardian.com]? Two women in NYC, both born on the same day, one black and one white, both called Lisa S Davis. The police were too lazy to differentiate, judges simply did not care. At least someone in the DMV did care (and remembered the situation when it happened again).
Re: (Score:2)
That sounds a bit . . . far fetched. All three of you being in the system as having been born on the same date (that includes the year).
I know three sisters whose birthdays are spread over 3-4 days, but the youngest one is two years younger than her eldest sister and all three of them were born on different days of that month. Their parents were also intelligent enough to give them different names.
Re: (Score:2)
I had a weird variation that wasnt fraud that there was a guy with my *exact name* , same age, and a whole bunch of details living around the corner from me, and I was constantly running into issues with the tax dept, debt collectors, you name it, and it was a compete fucking mystery to me , until one day the guys ex girlfriend tracy phoned me insisting I was her ex boyfriend until she realised my voice didnt match, and found out about him. I went around there with him, and gobsmackingly he even looked a bi
Re: (Score:2)
When I was a teenager there were two kids my age who went to the same summer camp and they shared the exact same name and DOB. They were also born pretty close geographically so they probably had SSN's that were very similar as well (that is more randomized nowadays).
Covered on Lehto's law (Score:4, Informative)
link [youtube.com]
"My Life Is Over" (Score:2)
No buddy, your life was over long ago. There was clearly a reason you assumed someone else's life. People don't go to the extent you did, "for the lulz"
Rusty? (Score:1)
Clear Example of the USA's Broken Indigent Defense (Score:1)
His real name was (Score:2)
Dr. Richard Kimble.